HackerZonHackerTube but for Amazon products mentioned on HN About

Medical Real Handheld Portable Monitor

Amazon's catalog no longer lists this product (checked 2026-11-02). The name comes from the link HN users posted.

When HN users recommended it

1 HN user recommended this in 2014, in one comment.

20072026

Each tall tick is one HN user's first recommendation. A short tick is the same user again. Click a tick to jump to the comment.

What HN users said

robbiep linked amazon.com View on HN
in Just had a heart attack, 6 replies deep

the technology is very simple and very old so without knowing what sort of machines they are (if they are like [1] then they are more for monitoring abberant rhythms than detecting infarcts or ischaemia - it doesn't have enough leads to properly detect a heart attack) they may do an ok job; the real question is of benefit. There is little benefit to be obtained from regular ECG in an otherwise healthy person. You can't/shouldn't perform a home exercise stress test as you need to be in a hospital environment so that you could be resuscitated if things go badly.

For data collection or your own interest, a proper 12 lead ECG is a great reference item; but again if the machine is like [1] you are only going to get this simple trace that doesn't tell you much; even serial ECG's on a normal healthy patient (or even someone with moderate heart disease) will be almost perfectly normal day to day, month to month at rest.

So I would be inclined to suggest that it is a bit of a waste of money from any attempt at home diagnostics, however if you were concerned about your cardiovascular risk you should discuss it with your doctor.

[1] http://www.amazon.com/Medical-Real-Handheld-Portable-Monitor...

Keyboard shortcuts

j kNext or previous comment
mShow more of the selected comment
hOpen the selected comment on HN
aView on Amazon
sSave or unsave
uBack to the list
/Search